top of page

Coaching vs. Managing: How a Shift in Mindset Transforms Teams

jbennett311

Coaching employees isn’t just a trend—it’s a powerful strategy that can transform how teams collaborate, innovate, and thrive. Imagine a manager named Brianna, who oversees a diverse group of professionals in a rapidly growing tech company. For a while, Brianna used traditional management techniques: she assigned tasks, set deadlines, and routinely checked in on progress. While this style ensured things got done, it left her employees feeling more like cogs in a machine than valued contributors. Over time, creativity waned, and trust began to erode. Team members would finish tasks out of obligation rather than ownership.


One day, Brianna decided to change her approach by adopting a coaching mindset. Instead of telling her staff exactly what to do, she started asking questions that encouraged them to think for themselves: “How would you handle this challenge?” or “What resources might help you solve this problem?” In addition to setting clear expectations, she deliberately left room for individual decision-making. As she shifted from directing tasks to nurturing potential, her employees found they had space to be more innovative. They began sharing fresh ideas, collaborating more freely, and even volunteering for new projects. Morale soared because people felt seen, heard, and empowered.


The difference between managing and coaching often comes down to motivation. Managers tend to focus on processes and outcomes—crucial elements, no doubt—but coaching taps into each employee’s personal drive for growth. Coaches actively listen, offer supportive feedback, and help team members set their own goals. Employees are more likely to feel invested in the outcome when they’re part of the decision-making process and can see how their work ties back to their personal development. Along the way, small moments of guidance and recognition foster a sense of mutual respect.



That’s not to say coaching is a free-for-all. Deadlines and performance standards still matter. The key is balancing accountability with respect for each person’s unique perspective. Brianna, for instance, continued to hold weekly check-ins and reviews, but she framed them around progress and obstacles rather than daily task lists. When issues arose, she encouraged employees to propose their own solutions first, coaching them to refine and implement these ideas. As a result, trust deepened and employees took more initiative—even outside of their usual roles.


Ultimately, coaching drives a culture of continuous learning and adaptability. By shifting to a coaching style, you create a workforce that doesn’t just wait for orders but actively seeks out new challenges. Employees learn to solve problems independently, support each other’s success, and align more closely with organizational goals. The impact extends beyond day-to-day tasks: it shapes the entire work environment, turning it into a space where people flourish.


If you’re ready to explore how a coaching approach can elevate your leadership style, Hyman Consulting is here to help. Contact us at info@hymanconsulting.com or visit www.hymanconsulting.com to discover our workshops, coaching sessions, and training materials designed to guide you every step of the way. Empowerment starts with how you lead, and coaching might be the key to unlocking your team’s fullest potential.

1 view0 comments

Comments


"You can't use up creativity. The more you use, the more you have."

- Maya Angelou

© 2023 by Hyman Consulting, LLC created with Wix.com

bottom of page